If your insurance costs $2,000 a year, is your agent keeping $800?
That’s what a 40% commission would look like. For the home, auto, and business insurance we’re talking about at Leal Insurance Services? No. Not even close.
The insurance companies we work with usually pay our agency a base commission of 10% to 12% of the policy premium. On a $2,000 annual policy, that’s $200 to $240 for the year, before agency expenses. Rates vary by company and policy, so those numbers describe how we’re typically paid at our agency.
Whether you’re shopping for car insurance, reviewing a homeowners renewal, or comparing quotes for your business, here’s how to tell what you’re paying and who’s getting paid.
What does a $200 insurance commission actually pay for?
Let’s stick with the $2,000 annual premium. At a 10% commission, the insurance company pays our agency $200 for that policy. You don’t get a separate $200 bill from us for the commission. And the $200 is agency revenue before we pay the team, the office bills, or the software that helps us keep track of your requests. My payroll would like a word with anyone who calls that pure profit.
Think about what happens after you buy a policy. You trade in your car and need to update your insurance before you leave the dealership. Your homeowners renewal shows a change in how the insurer would pay for covered roof damage, and you want somebody to explain what it means. Or you land a commercial job and the general contractor needs a certificate of insurance before your crew can start.
That’s the work the commission helps pay for. Some people go a whole year without needing much from us. Others call three times in a month because life doesn’t check your renewal date before changing the plans.
What’s the difference between a commission and an agency fee?
A commission is paid by the insurance company to the agency. An agency fee is a separate charge you pay to the agency.
At Leal Insurance Services, we generally don’t charge a separate agency fee for personal home or auto insurance. If you see a charge for paying in installments, that may be a billing fee from the insurance company. Ask who’s charging it and what it’s for.
On certain business insurance accounts, we charge a one-time agency fee for the policy term and disclose it before you buy. Some accounts take more work to quote and service. A contractor might need several policies, regular certificates, help sorting through a contract’s insurance requirements, and guidance on what records to gather for a premium audit. The fee helps cover the cost of staffing that work.
A separate fee is a fair thing to ask about. If one shows up on your quote, ask: “What’s the total I’ll pay for the policy term, and what does this fee cover?” That gives you a better comparison than lining up the premiums alone.
If the insurance company pays us, whose side are we on?
You’re right to ask. If the commission percentage stays the same and your premium goes up, the agency can earn more. At 10%, a $500 annual premium increase means $50 more in agency revenue. You’re still the one paying the extra $500, and you deserve a clear explanation of your options.
We’re an independent insurance agency. We work with multiple insurance companies, which gives us options when your needs change or your renewal comes in higher than expected. Our loyalty is to our customers. We’ll explain why we’d recommend staying put or switching based on the options we can offer.
Say another homeowners quote saves you a few hundred dollars a year but comes with a higher wind and hail deductible. You may decide the savings are worth it. Our job is to show you what you’d have to pay out of pocket for a covered loss before you make that call. The same goes for a cheaper auto or business policy with different limits or exclusions. You should know what you’re trading for the lower price.
If you’re comparing home, auto, or business insurance quotes in Texas and a line item doesn’t make sense, call Leal Insurance Services at (210) 277-7544. Ask us what it costs, what changed, and why we’re recommending it. You should get a straight answer.
Frequently asked questions
Do insurance agents get 40% of your premium?
That’s not how Leal Insurance Services is typically paid for the home, auto, and business policies discussed here. Our usual base commission is 10% to 12% of the premium. Compensation can vary by insurance company, policy, and agency.
Does using an independent insurance agent cost extra?
A carrier-paid commission isn’t a separate bill from your agent. Some agencies charge separate fees, so ask for the total cost before you buy. At Leal Insurance Services, we generally don’t charge agency fees for personal home or auto insurance.
Why does my business insurance quote include an agency fee?
Some commercial accounts require more time to set up and service. At Leal Insurance Services, when a one-time agency fee applies for a policy term, we disclose it before you buy. Ask what the fee covers and how it affects your total cost.
Does my agent make more if my premium goes up?
They can. If the commission rate stays at 10% and the annual premium rises from $2,000 to $2,500, the agency’s commission rises from $200 to $250. Ask your agent to explain the renewal and walk you through any available alternatives.
What should I compare besides the price of an insurance quote?
Compare the same policy term, coverage limits, deductibles, exclusions, and any separate fees. If one quote costs less, ask what changed and what that could mean for you if you have a claim.
Read more from Leal Insurance Services
- Does Your Business Insurance Cover AI Mistakes?
- How Do Insurance Agents Get Paid? The Truth About the 40% Commission Claim
- What Happens If Your Tools Are Stolen Tonight? A Contractor’s Guide to Protecting Tools, Trailers, and Equipment
- Why General Contractors Reject Your Certificate of Insurance (And How to Fix It)
- Why AI Shouldn’t Replace Your Accountant, Attorney, or Insurance Agent

