Running a nonprofit means wearing a lot of hats.
One minute you’re planning a fundraiser. The next you’re meeting with donors, recruiting volunteers, managing staff, and figuring out how to stretch every dollar a little further.
With so much happening, insurance usually isn’t at the top of the priority list.
And that’s understandable.
The problem is that many nonprofit leaders assume they’re protected simply because they have insurance. Unfortunately, having insurance and having the right insurance aren’t always the same thing.
I’ve worked with nonprofit organizations long enough to see a pattern. Most coverage gaps aren’t discovered during an annual renewal—they’re discovered after a claim has already happened.
By then, it’s too late to make changes.
The good news is that most of these problems are preventable.
Let’s walk through seven of the biggest insurance mistakes I see nonprofits make and how you can avoid them.
1. Assuming General Liability Covers Everything
General liability insurance is one of the most important policies a nonprofit can have, but it’s also one of the most misunderstood.
It helps protect your organization if someone is injured on your property, if you accidentally damage someone else’s property, or if certain advertising-related claims arise.
That’s important coverage.
But that’s not where the story ends.
General liability typically doesn’t cover:
- Employment-related lawsuits
- Claims against board members
- Cyberattacks
- Employee theft
- Professional mistakes while providing services
Imagine someone slips on a wet sidewalk outside your office. General liability may help.
Now imagine a former employee files a wrongful termination lawsuit.
That’s a completely different type of claim and usually requires different coverage.
One insurance policy rarely protects against every risk your nonprofit faces.
2. Not Carrying Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance
People join nonprofit boards because they care about the mission—not because they expect to get sued.
Unfortunately, lawsuits don’t always care about good intentions.
Directors & Officers (D&O) insurance helps protect board members, officers, and organizational leaders when decisions they make are challenged.
Claims can come from:
- Employees
- Donors
- Members
- Vendors
- Government agencies
Some common allegations include:
- Wrongful termination
- Discrimination
- Financial mismanagement
- Breach of fiduciary duty
- Governance disputes
Even if your organization ultimately wins the case, legal defense can be expensive.
Without D&O coverage, board members could find themselves paying legal expenses out of their own pockets.
That’s a difficult conversation no nonprofit wants to have with the volunteers who generously give their time.
3. Underinsuring Your Property
Everything costs more than it did just a few years ago.
Construction materials.
Labor.
Technology.
Office furniture.
Equipment.
Building repairs.
Yet many nonprofit organizations are still carrying property limits based on values from years ago.
That’s a recipe for trouble.
If your building is insured for $1 million but rebuilding it would actually cost $1.5 million today, your organization could be responsible for the difference after a major loss.
And don’t forget about everything inside the building.
Ask yourself:
- Have you upgraded computers?
- Added security cameras?
- Purchased audio/visual equipment?
- Expanded office furniture?
- Invested in specialized equipment?
Those purchases add up.
An annual review should focus on today’s replacement costs—not what those items were worth when the policy was first written.
4. Ignoring Cyber Risks
Many nonprofit leaders assume cybercriminals only target large corporations.
Unfortunately, that’s not how cybercrime works anymore.
In fact, nonprofits are often attractive targets because they store valuable information while operating with limited technology budgets.
Think about the data your organization collects.
You may have:
- Donor information
- Credit card payment details
- Volunteer records
- Employee information
- Financial records
- Grant information
A ransomware attack or data breach can quickly become one of the most expensive events your organization ever experiences.
The cost isn’t limited to recovering lost files.
There may also be expenses for:
- Computer forensic investigations
- Attorney fees
- Notification requirements
- Credit monitoring
- Public relations
- Business interruption
Cyber insurance isn’t just for technology companies.
If your nonprofit uses email, stores donor information, or accepts online donations, cyber risk deserves your attention.
5. Overlooking Volunteer Liability
Volunteers are the heartbeat of many nonprofit organizations.
Without them, many missions simply couldn’t happen.
But volunteers also create unique insurance exposures that are often overlooked.
For example:
What happens if a volunteer causes a car accident while running errands for your organization?
What if a volunteer accidentally injures a guest during an event?
What happens if a volunteer is injured while helping your nonprofit?
The answers depend on your policies.
Every nonprofit uses volunteers differently, which means every organization should review how those volunteers are covered.
Protecting your volunteers also helps protect your mission.
6. Forgetting to Review Insurance Before Special Events
Fundraisers.
Galas.
Charity golf tournaments.
Community festivals.
Silent auctions.
These events are fantastic opportunities to engage donors and raise money.
They’re also some of the biggest sources of unexpected insurance claims.
Every event is a little different.
You may have:
- Outside vendors
- Food trucks
- Live entertainment
- Alcohol service
- Temporary structures
- Hundreds of guests
Those details matter.
Some venues require additional insured status.
Some events require special event coverage.
Some activities increase your liability exposure significantly.
A quick conversation with your insurance advisor before your next fundraiser can help identify potential gaps long before opening day.
7. Never Reviewing Coverage as Your Organization Grows
Your nonprofit today probably doesn’t look exactly like it did three years ago.
Maybe you’ve hired staff.
Expanded programs.
Purchased a building.
Added vehicles.
Started accepting online donations.
Opened a second location.
Partnered with another organization.
Growth is exciting.
But every change can create new insurance needs.
One of the easiest ways to reduce your risk is by scheduling an annual insurance review.
A yearly conversation gives you the opportunity to:
- Update property values
- Review new programs
- Discuss cyber risks
- Evaluate volunteer activities
- Confirm board coverage
- Identify new exposures before they become expensive claims
Insurance shouldn’t stay the same while your organization changes.
Final Thoughts
Most nonprofit insurance claims don’t begin because someone ignored the rules.
They begin because someone assumed they were already protected.
“We thought our policy covered that.”
“We didn’t realize we needed another policy.”
“We’ve always done it this way.”
Those assumptions can become very expensive.
The good news is that most coverage gaps can be identified long before a lawsuit or claim ever happens.
A little planning today can help protect your organization, your board, your donors, and the mission you’ve worked so hard to build.
If it’s been more than a year since your nonprofit reviewed its insurance program, now is a great time to schedule that conversation.
Your future self—and your board—will thank you.
Frequently Asked Questions
What insurance does every nonprofit need?
Most nonprofits should consider general liability, directors and officers (D&O) insurance, commercial property insurance, cyber liability insurance, workers’ compensation (where required), commercial auto coverage if vehicles are used, and crime coverage. The right combination depends on your organization’s activities and risks.
What does D&O insurance cover for nonprofits?
D&O insurance helps protect board members, officers, and organizational leaders from claims alleging wrongful acts in managing the nonprofit. It often includes defense costs for allegations such as wrongful termination, discrimination, breach of fiduciary duty, or financial mismanagement.
Is cyber insurance necessary for a nonprofit?
Yes. Many nonprofits collect donor information, payment data, employee records, and other sensitive information. Cyber insurance can help cover costs related to data breaches, ransomware attacks, legal expenses, notification requirements, and business interruption.
Are volunteers covered by nonprofit insurance?
Not always. Volunteer coverage varies depending on the policy and the activities being performed. It’s important to review how volunteers are protected before an incident occurs.
Should nonprofits have insurance for fundraising events?
Many events create additional risks that may require endorsements or separate event coverage. It’s best to review each fundraiser, gala, tournament, or community event with your insurance advisor before the event takes place.
How often should a nonprofit review its insurance?
At least once a year, and anytime your organization experiences significant changes such as new programs, additional staff, property purchases, expansion, or major fundraising events.
Read our latest blog post specifically written for Texas Business Owners:
- Water Damage and Your Home Insurance: What Most Texas Homeowners Don’t Find Out Until It’s Too Late
- The Hidden Insurance Risks of Fundraisers, Festivals, and Community Events
- Can Nonprofit Board Members Be Personally Sued? What Every Director Needs to Know
- The 7 Insurance Mistakes That Put Nonprofit Organizations One Lawsuit Away From Disaster
- The Insurance Coverage Most Texas Contractors Think They Have… But Usually Don’t